I'm in the middle of teaching about worship and it would surprise nobody to hear that my students are completely unfamiliar with the hymnal. We don't have new hymnals, so I have to use 
Lutheran Worship, but as my goal is to show what a useful book it is and introduce my students to the many different types of services there are, it will do for me.
As I was writing it, I realized that it might be beneficial for many others as well, so here is the link for a 
LW HYMNAL SCAVENGER HUNT!  You also might be able to adapt it to the newer hymnal or any other hymnal you use.